Court throws out FMCSA's $73.5 million penalty on New York over non-domiciled CDL expiration dates: what the ruling does and doesn't change
The Second Circuit said the rules in force before September 2025 never required states to match a non-domiciled CDL's expiration to the driver's immigration papers. The newer rule that does is a separate matter.

A federal appeals court on Nov. 13 set aside the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's decision to withhold $73,502,543 in highway funding from New York over how the state set expiration dates on non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit granted New York's petition for review in State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation (No. 26-1097), according to the court's opinion. The court found FMCSA's final determination was arbitrary, capricious or contrary to law.
What the court decided
The case turned on one question: did the federal rules in place before September 2025 require states to make a non-domiciled CDL expire no later than the driver's lawful presence documents?
The court said no. Under those rules, states had to issue non-domiciled licenses using procedures at least identical to those for any other CDL, with a maximum validity of eight years. Applicants had to show an unexpired employment authorization document, or an unexpired foreign passport with an approved I-94, when they applied. Nothing in the text required the license itself to end when those papers did, and the opinion notes that FMCSA conceded the plain text did not contain an expiration-matching requirement.
Judge Nathan wrote the opinion for the panel. Judge Schwartz agreed with the result but wrote separately, saying the court should have stopped at the plain text.
How the dispute started
According to the opinion:
- FMCSA began its annual review of New York's licensing program in July 2025.
- As of July 2025, New York had about 32,600 non-domiciled CDL and CLP holders, roughly 7% of its active commercial licenses and permits.
- New York issued those licenses for five years at first issuance and eight years on renewal, the same as for other drivers.
- FMCSA sampled 200 non-domiciled CDLs and CLPs and found 101 that stayed valid after the lawful presence documents expired.
- Its preliminary finding told New York to pause issuing non-domiciled CLPs and CDLs and to void or rescind the unexpired licenses it considered noncompliant.
- In April 2026, FMCSA made a final determination and withheld 4% of New York's federal-aid highway funds for fiscal year 2027, warning that up to 8%, or $147,005,086, could follow in later years.
What it doesn't change
The ruling is about the old rules only. The opinion lays out the newer ones separately:
- In late September 2025, FMCSA issued an interim final rule requiring states to make sure a non-domiciled CLP or CDL is not valid past the Admit Until Date or expiration date on the applicant's immigration documents. The D.C. Circuit stayed that interim rule.
- In February 2026, FMCSA adopted the same language in a final rule after public comment. It took effect March 16, 2026, and in May the D.C. Circuit refused to stay it while the challenge continues.
Judge Schwartz's concurrence notes that those amendments face ongoing litigation in other circuits.
What it means for drivers and carriers
For a driver holding a non-domiciled CDL, the practical rule today comes from the 2026 final rule, not from this decision. The opinion does not say anything about the status of individual licenses already issued in New York.
Carriers that employ drivers with non-domiciled CDLs should keep tracking the expiration date on each license and on the driver's work authorization, and watch for any further action in this case or in the challenges to the 2026 rule.